In LATE NIGHT WITH THE DEVIL (2023), a talk show host hopes to revive his flagging career and ratings with a Halloween special. The result is a work of found footage horror that boldly distinguishes itself from that genre while keeping things simple.
It’s 1977, and NIGHT OWLS host Jack Delroy (David Dastmalchian) has entertained the nation for five years as a late night talk show host, though his ratings never beat Johnny Carson’s, and his career is flagging, particularly after the death of his wife. After a hiatus marked with grief, he decides to stage a comeback. LATE NIGHT WITH THE DEVIL starts with a documentary look at Delroy’s career and then presents footage from the grisly episode, including behind-the-scenes footage.
Delroy is a great character in that he is highly sympathetic and we can root for him, but he has a tragic flaw, which is his drive to beat Johnny Carson in ratings and host the number one show on TV. As the Halloween episode proceeds through its guests, we see both sides of him propelling himself and his show to both potentially realizing his goal and a terrifying confrontation.
The movie does a great job imagining a 1970s late night talk show, complete with stilted on-air banter, constant asides for a quick and easy laugh, fashions, technical dialogue and equipment, and the usual personalities including the band and the show’s hapless sidekick, excellently portrayed by Rhys Auteri. It all proves nicely immersive for the horror element that comes crashing in.
And when it does, there’s quite a payoff. One of those rare horror scenes where I start laughing, not because it’s funny but because it’s awesome. From the beginning of the NIGHT OWLS episode, Delroy tells us we will meet several guests. It all builds up to Lilly (with Ingrid Torelli fantastic in the role), a young girl who grew up in a Satanic cult and is the sole survivor. Her therapist became her guardian, and their sessions formed the basis of the therapist’s book CONVERSATIONS WITH THE DEVIL.
At Delroy’s urging, they do one of their sessions for the studio audience…
Some found the ending ambiguous, though I thought it was clear enough. The story makes sense, but at the end, you may have the feeling that there might have been a bit more to tie things off. I was okay with it, all things said. Though the movie teased aspirations that went beyond found footage, in the end it stayed true to the form.
Overall, I thought LATE NIGHT WITH THE DEVIL was a lot of fun and would recommend it to horror fans looking for something fresh.