I greatly enjoyed Tim Lebbon’s apocalyptic horror novel THE SILENCE, and Netflix’s 2019 film adaptation is fairly faithful and well executed. It was an enjoyable movie, despite some flaws.

First, let’s dispense with THE QUIET PLACE. From what I’ve read, the script for that movie was in the works before Lebbon’s novel came out, so neither may be a direct knockoff of the other. Both have strengths and flaws and neither in my view is that much better than the other. What made THE QUIET PLACE more effective was the much stronger use of silence to build tension (I was holding my breath during parts), while THE SILENCE is more effective in showing how the creatures spread and end up dominating the world’s ecosystem. THE QUIET PLACE hit me in the gut, while THE SILENCE hit me in the head. Similarly, I didn’t find it any better or worse than BIRD BOX, also fun but flawed.

In THE SILENCE, deep cave exploration opens up a ecosystem allowing a swarm of batlike creatures to escape. These creatures multiply quickly in balance with their food supply, and suddenly, they’re at the top of a seemingly bottomless food chain. I love that kind of apocalypse, where a new creature is introduced that isn’t evil but simply wants to eat and sees humans as food, displacing humanity in the food chain. Their weakness is they evolved in darkness and cannot see, so they navigate (and hunt) entirely by sound waves. As they rapidly spread, a family (fathered by the great Stanley Tucci) decides to flee to somewhere remote. The story focuses on their journey and subsequent survival where they end up. Spicing things up is the daughter (Kiernan Shipka, the poor man’s Emma Watson) is deaf, and the whole family communicates by sign language, which gives them an advantage in this dangerous new world.

The film handles all this competently, and if you like apocalyptic fare, there’s plenty of fun here, though there isn’t much going on with the characters. The daughter has the potential of transforming from shy young woman with a disability to a leader, but that doesn’t play out. The father has the potential of transforming from a timid, civilized, middle-aged man into a tribal leader who will do anything for his tribe (like the dad in THE QUIET PLACE), but no character arc is apparent. As a result, all the struggle is with the creatures, though we don’t see the characters really suffer for it or be affected by it much internally once they reach a sanctuary. As for external struggle, there isn’t that much until they find sanctuary. The film then runs into the same issue as the otherwise fantastic book–the monsters play themselves out as a threat, and a human threat is introduced, which in turn plays itself out before coming to an abrupt end. The result is a film that is titillating but somewhat emotionally flat.

Overall, I liked THE SILENCE and give is a B as a movie and B+ as an apocalyptic movie.

Despite an intriguing premise and a major John Carpenter vibe, DISCARNATE (2018) is a hot mess express, though it manages to gain some coherence by the end.

The film begins with Dr. Andre Mason’s (Thomas Kretschmann) child dying, which sets him on the path to find out what happened to him and also to determine if there’s life after death. Fast forward to him receiving a drug from a woman named Maya (the gorgeous Nadine Velazquez) that facilitates contact with the spirit world, and then fast forward to Mason and his group of researchers testing the drug. Of course things are going to go wrong, and I’m looking forward to it. I’m picturing I’m in store for HELL HOUSE meets SILENT HILL, which would have been super cool.

Unfortunately, the wonkiness of the first act’s pacing starts to seep into the characters, dialogue, and everything else. The researchers all take the drug and then wander off to do their own thing. There’s zero scientific protocol to make the experiment seem even remotely authentic. The monitor from the organization funding the experiment plays the jerk seemingly just to be a jerk.

Then things go to hell fast. There’s little contact with spirits but the real threat isn’t them but a formless creature that feeds on the living so as to become mortal again. The more of the drug the researchers take, the more the creature is able to notice and interact with them, putting them all in danger. It’s here the film gains some coherence to come in for a solid landing.

The film has a lot going for it, there are things to like here, and it’s obvious real love and a lot of work went into it. There’s some decent creep factor, the premise is terrific, and the creature is pretty good. But it falls apart with sloppy dialogue, odd pacing, and too much going on in a scientific experiment that doesn’t remotely behave like one. I have to give DISCARNATE a C+, though dedicated horror fans might love it.